Friday, 22 February 2008

Web Pioneer Quits OpenSolaris Project

Web Pioneer Quits OpenSolaris Project - A high-profile amount in Sun Microsystems' OpenSolaris association has quit, accusing Sun of application too abundant ascendancy over the open-source analogue to its Solaris operating system.

Roy Fielding, co-founder of the Apache HTTP Server Activity and a key contributor to the Hypertext Transfer Protocol, appear his abandonment aftermost anniversary in a bulletin on the community's altercation forum.

"Sun didn't aloof accomplish ambiguous statements to me about OpenSolaris; they fabricated promises about it actuality an accessible development project. That's the alone way they could get addition like me to accommodate chargeless activity for their benefit," he wrote in the bulletin anachronous Feb. 14. That hasn't happened, Fielding argued.

"Sun agreed that 'OpenSolaris' would be absolute by the association and yet has refused, in every footfall forth the way, to abalienate any absolute ascendancy over the software produced or the way it is produced, and continues to accomplish clandestine decisions every day that are after answer as decisions for this affair we alarm OpenSolaris," he wrote.

OpenSolaris consists of an open-source cipher base, accoutrement and a association of developers, not an end-user-ready distribution. Various distributions employing OpenSolaris accept been released.

Sun should accept the administering appearance of MySQL, the open-source database aggregation Sun is acquiring, Fielding wrote. "That aggregation doesn't pretend to let their association participate in decisions, and yet they still administer to amuse best of their users. . . There's annihilation decidedly amiss with that best — it is a altogether accurate open-source archetypal for corporations that don't charge alive association participation."

Fielding did not acknowledge to a appeal for added comment.

Terri Molini, an OpenSolaris advancement contributor at Sun, responded to Fielding's accuse in a able account Wednesday.

"As a consultant, Roy was acutely accessible during the birth of the OpenSolaris association as able-bodied as an aboriginal affiliate of the [OpenSolaris Administering Board]. His captivation with the association and his contributions in the conception of the babyminding archetypal were invaluable. Sun wishes him able-bodied in all of his endeavors," she wrote.

"Open antecedent technologies accept abounding stakeholders and Sun is alive with as abounding communities as accessible to actualize an accessible antecedent administration of OpenSolaris," she continued. "We admit that we will not be able to amuse anybody as we move through this action and in some cases, we'll accept to accede to disagree on some points."

One abutting eyewitness of OpenSolaris had a alloyed acknowledgment to Fielding's decision.

"There's a altercation here; there's a flare-up," said Stephen O'Grady, an analyst at RedMonk. "It looks bad, but the annotation itself is not aberrant in the open-source community."

Given Fielding's cachet as a technologist, his abandonment will accept some effect, but won't cripple, the project, O'Grady said. "Certainly it's a [public relations] hit. ... But this isn't Linus Torvalds abrogation Linux."

Read more on this Web Pioneer Quits OpenSolaris Project

No comments: